Standard Mortgage Financial Services, Inc.

Your Source for Mortgage Loans

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Loan Application
    • Apply Online
    • Loan Application (PDF)
  • News Blog
    • Borrower Blog
    • Investor Blog
    • R.E. Professionals Blog
  • About Us
    • Jeff Heib
    • Pam Sosa
  • Testimonials
  • History
  • Privacy
You are here: Home / Archives for Orcilla vs. Big Sur Inc.

The Inability to Pay Is Immaterial: Orcilla Lowers the Standard

September 14, 2016 By Jeff Heib

A 2016 California appellate court ruling, Orcilla vs. Big Sur, Inc., has introduced new uncertainty to the ever-more-complex arena of real estate investing. The ruling found that the original buyers of a property can challenge a foreclosure if the circumstances at the time of origination — in this case, the inability of the buyers to afford their payment — are deemed unconscionable.

house-photo
What does this mean for the investor whose portfolio contains non-performing notes or the institutions that handle such loans? Read on to learn more about the Orcilla ruling and its potential impact on the real estate market.

A Brief Overview of the Orcilla Case

A company named Quick Loan gave the Orcillas, a couple with limited English comprehension, a refinance loan in 2006. The terms led to a monthly payment that exceeded the couple’s take home income by more than 30 percent. After an initial default, the foreclosing lender proposed a loan modification that increased the monthly payment by several hundred dollars. The second default resulted in the sale of the home to a third party, who eventually evicted the Orcillas. Meanwhile, Quick Loan had lost its license for using trustee money to purchase casino markers.

This cautionary tale of the pre-recessionary lending market and its most egregious practices would have come to nothing had the Orcillas not appealed when their initial claim was dismissed. In spite of the fact that they could not prove material damages, the appellate court ruled that the loan was so procedurally unconscionable that it met the standard for substantive unconscionability even though the Orcillas did not meet all of the elements of their claim.

The Possible Impact of Orcilla on the Real Estate Investment Market

The Orcilla case against the bona fide purchaser, Big Sur, is concerning for several reasons. First, the claim of substantive unconscionability rendered the fact that the Orcillas were not able to make good on the loan immaterial; in this ruling, procedural mistakes trump the debtor’s ability to pay. Second, the ruling overlooking existing laws designed to protect the consumer from fraud and opened the door to a much broader and ill-defined set of challenges.

Most importantly, though, the ruling sweeps aside the rights and protections of BFPs who act in good faith when taking over a defaulted loan. If the Orcilla ruling sets the precedent for other states, the foreclosure market will become a lot more uncertain; investors and lenders alike may become unduly cautious about investing in the scratch and dent market for fear of losing monies because of unknown irregularities in the original loan documents.

Peak Foreclosure Services, Inc. specializes in a wide range of default servicing solutions to support and meet the needs of banks, private investors, servicers, and sub-servicers. The company offers both judicial and non-judicial in-house foreclosure services, reconveyance, post foreclosure services, and loss mitigation in eleven states –- A rizona, California, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, Texas, and Washington. They also offer national foreclosure referral services through carefully selected counsel and handle everything from payment processing to foreclosure and bankruptcy processing, REO repair, and disposition services. They are a true one-stop solution for all their clients’ foreclosure servicing needs.

Filed Under: Borrowers, Investors, Real Estate Professionals Tagged With: Orcilla vs. Big Sur Inc.

Subscribe for FREE Updates

Subscribe to our free newsletter and receive the "Social Media Power" ebook for free ($14.95 value). Limited Time Offer

Click here to Subscribe

Standard Mortgage Financial Services, Inc.
6700 Indiana Avenue, Suite 220
Riverside, CA 92506
Phone (951) 686-9639
Toll Free (800) 476-5626
Jeff's Direct Line (562) 806-2921
Fax (951) 686-0361
California BRE #01211863

Recent Posts

  • COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Information and Resources
  • Mortgage e-Alert: Pending California Legislation
  • CalBRE Licensee Alert: Issued March 2017
  • Mortgage e-Alert: HUD/FHA and other news
  • MORTGAGE e-ALERT: THE MOST COMMON VIOLATIONS FOUND IN CALBRE AUDITS

Categories

Tags

660 ficos 680 ficos 1031 Exchange affordable housing balloon payments bankruptcy California Association of Mortgage Professionals CAMP consumer financial protection bureau consumer loans department of real estate Dodd Frank dre regs Duane Gomer fannie mae federal trade commission foreclosure freddie mac Herman Thordsen high LTV loans home sales housing applications installments interest only late charges loan collections monthly loan payments Occupy Wall Street OWS private lending private real estate loans property values Prospect Mortgage Raul Camaligan real estate loans RESPA reverse mortgage single family owner occupied software Standard & Poor's Thordsen Law Offices trust deed Truth in Lending Act unemployment benefits Wells Fargo

News from the Blog

COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Information and Resources

CDC: Interim Guidance for Businesses and EmployersSBA: Small Business Guidance and Loan ResourcesScore: Small Business … [Read More...]

Mortgage e-Alert: Pending California Legislation

(4-24-2017) - From our good friends at the Thordsen Law Offices: PENDING CALIFORNIA LEGISLATION THAT AFFECTS REAL ESTATE … [Read More...]

Subscribe for FREE Updates

Click here to Subscribe

Follow Our Blogs

Borrowers
Investors
Real Estate Professionals

Categories

Standard Mortgage Financial Services, Inc.
6700 Indiana Avenue Suite 220
Riverside, CA 92506-1827
Phone (951) 686-9639
Toll Free (800) 476-5626
Jeff's Direct Line (562) 806-2921
Fax (951) 686-0361
California BRE #01211863

Copyright © 2022 Standard Mortgage Financial Services, Inc. | Website by The Burrell Group · Log in